Thursday, July 10, 2014

Israelis and Palestinians have forgotten how this war began

The Israel Air Force has attacked more than 500 targets in the Gaza Strip in the last 48 hours, a trade of barbs with the near equal number of rockets fired at Israel, 30 of them long range to Tel Aviv northward, since the operation began.

As Palestinians and Israelis take cover on either side of the Gaza border, it seems both have forgotten why this war started in the first place.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu tiptoed into this operation last week carefully and hesitatingly, knowing neither side was interested in an escalation. Netanyahu knew that an all-out war would end not only in bloodshed, but in further international isolation for Israel.

When his foreign minister and faction partner Avigdor Lieberman publicly split with him over their policy in Gaza, Netanyahu was forced into action: a ruthless aerial campaign over the Strip to prove Israel's steadfastness in responding to rocket fire. This was a reality even right-wing Netanyahu wanted to avoid, but the barrage of rockets and the political pressure left him little choice.

As the operation enters its third day, Netanyahu is helpless to the fact that a ground incursion may be next on the agenda. This is certainly Hamas' aspiration, seen by its naval incursion Tuesday and subsequent failed attempt on Wednesday.

A ground incursion would mean fewer losses for Gaza, as the battles pinpoint on its own territory where it can fight with more control using weapons it has en masse that are easier to attain than the long-range missiles no longer readily available from its former benefactors in Iran. This would also give it a chance to wipe out Israeli forces in a way impossible under aerial strike – Hamas has already fired anti-aircraft missiles at Israeli jets, but its arsenal is limited and cannot be wasted for that effort.

Netanyahu said at the outset that neither Israel nor Hamas wanted escalation. The fragile Palestinian unity pact served for both as a deterrent. Hamas is weaker than ever, abandoned by Syria and Iran, and humiliated by Egypt, which has outlawed its allied Muslim Brotherhood and acted brutally to destroy the smuggling tunnels between Gaza and Sinai. Hamas' call to the Palestinian Authority was desperate, a last-ditch attempt to hover above water and maintain political and military legitimacy while hobbling on its last leg.

Israel recognized this weakness and sought to prevent reconciliation, in order to keep Mahmoud Abbas' Palestinian Authority clean and willing to concede to the conditions neither side managed to agree on in the exhausting nine months of failed peace negotiations.

Egypt's efforts to stymie Hamas' terrorist activities have been even significantly harsher than Israel's: it has repeatedly flooded its tunnels with sewage and destroyed hundreds of homes in the vicinity, damming not only Hamas' military capabilities but also its economic income, swallowing the profits that the Islamic organization has made over the years in illegal imports and taxation.

In the recent escalation, Hamas has suffered more losses in terms of strikes and casualties than Israel – hundreds of aerial attacks and more than two dozen killed – but has scored a victory with its surprise launching of at least three M-302 missiles, the longest-range projectiles in its cache, capable of reaching 200 km when lightly loaded and 150 km with a significant amount of warheads (145 kg). Its accuracy rate is within one kilometer, like its mid-range counterpart, the M-75 (similar to the Iranian Fajr). With just around 50 of these M-302s left in its arsenal, Hamas cannot afford to fire them at Israel with abandon.

These long-range missiles have already hit near Haifa's power station, and in Hadera – near the country's main power plant, and the only Israeli city to have absorbed missile attacks from both Gaza and from Lebanon in 2006. Hamas has also fired its mid-range missiles at Dimona, a mere few kilometers from Israel's nuclear reactor.

Its attacks are not indiscriminate: less targeted perhaps within Tel Aviv, to scare the public with albeit marginally inaccurate launches, but precise in attempt to demolish the infrastructure at energy and army bases. In addition to the few dozen M-302 remaining, there are a few hundred more M-75 mid-range projectiles in the Gaza cache, most in Hamas' cache and the rest overseen by the Islamic Jihad.

As the battle between Gaza and Israel escalates, the highways of Israel are now quiet, a far cry from the boiling Arab and Jewish riots over the kidnappings and deaths of the three Israeli and one Palestinian teens last week. Details of 16-year-old Mohammed Abu Khdeir's murder, apparently at the hands of Jewish extremists, are still under gag order, but the anger and calls for revenge have subsided into oblivion. If nothing, the Gaza front has calmed the embers in Jerusalem and the West Bank.

One should remember, however, that these were the embers that sparked the Gaza escalation. Without the rockets and the aerial strikes, media discourse and public outrage would still be focused on sectarian divides and a third intifada, and a demand to hunt the perpetrators of all four teenaged deaths, who have still not been verified or tried – and in the case of the West Bank kidnapping, have not even been found.

The cost of civilian life ranks high on Netanyahu's agenda, following the lessons of the previous Gaza wars in 2012 and 2009, and especially in Lebanon in 2006; less so in Gaza, where Hamas has stored caches of long-range missiles under civilian buildings, inviting Israeli strikes. Hamas has little to lose these days; its political, military and economic stability is at stake and it will not survive without the reinstated support of Iran or Syria, or alternately, a strong Palestinian Authority that recognizes it demands and bounds.

Fears of a Jewish-Arab backlash within the bounds of recognized Israel have been put on the back-burner for now, as have the prospects of renewed peace negotiations, while Israel and Gaza focus on the next mission at hand: destroying the other's resolve and securing international support.

Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Expected but not surprised: Hamas hits Tel Aviv

Israel's mostly complacent public in the center of the country is at war again, but is likely to forget this by the time the next cease-fire is declared within a few days or at worst, weeks. For most Israelis, the threat from the south –as the fronts on the east and the north - is a mere inconvenience, and proof that peace with the Palestinians is impossible.

Hamas to them is an illegitimate anti-Israeli entity whose revenge can be harsh, but only brief, while the recognized Palestinian Authority is the force that must be reckoned and reasoned with, though there too, most Israelis – despite the overwhelming number in favor of a two-state solution - see no partner, regardless of its overtures. This war is to the Israeli public another brief disturbance and another nail in the coffin of the peace process.
War in Israel since the second intifada, for most of the country's secular and moderately religious society, is a passing affair: while the south sustains massive hits on a daily and weekly basis, as East Jerusalem and the West Bank burn and Gaza is ruthlessly attacked, residents in the center of the country run fearfully with the spontaneous sirens and return to normalcy just as quickly. The same is true of the south, but the rate and frequency with which they are attacked has forced them into a more sober reality.

This month's conflict was spurred in the West Bank, with the kidnap and murder of three Israeli teens, and the subsequent revenge attack of a Palestinian of the same age. These events, which broiled the extreme right-wing in Jerusalem and the parts of West Bank, have taken a back burner now that Gaza has returned to the map.

As the rocket barrages burst into the center of Israel on Tuesday, an inconclusive five-star and star-studded affair with war on its agenda took place: Haaretz's acclaimed Israel's Conference on Peace. And there were even fireworks to punctuate the event.

Dozens of rockets were fired at Israel over the course of the evening – one over Tel Aviv in early evening and at least seven more in the center of the country after dark, including four identified in Jerusalem and a siren near the main power plant in Caesarea for the first time since the 2006 war in Lebanon - each met with slight alarm from residents and a quick return to business as usual. The southern city of Ashdod, once an anomaly and now a regular target, sustained multiple direct hits as well.

As Israel's leading politicians and security experts – Tzipi Livni, Yuval Diskin, Shimon Peres and more - rubbed elbows with its leftist elite and journalists at the conference in Tel Aviv, jihadists in the Gaza Strip took the opportunity to fire at the country's commercial and population center, intercepted just south of the city by the Iron Dome defense system. Participants of the peace conference learned of the sirens minutes later, and crowded the basement lobby to reassure friends and family that they were okay, and oh, how ironic.

As these center communities panicked, unused to rockets like their southern neighbors are,the Israel Air Force continued its attacks on militants in the Gaza Strip, killing at least nine throughout the day.

A short hour after the first Tel Aviv siren and before the nighttime barrage, Barack Obama's special assistant on the Middle East wrapped up Haaretz's peace conference calling on Israel to defend itself but to act responsibly, recalling Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's own urging the evening before.
This call by Netanyahu was made Sunday night, just hours before Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman took his Yisrael Beiteinu faction out of its alliance with Likud - a clear prompt tothe prime minister to rethink his strategy and political support, and order the IDF to prepare for a ground incursion - a move he had adamantly tried to prevent, and which he agreed to in the wake of the political splint.

Hamas claimed responsibility for the four rockets fired at Jerusalem and the two at Tel Aviv on Tuesday night, declaring them M 75 missiles, the Islamist organization's greatest weapon so far. An M 75 missile is designed to reach that many kilometers when loaded with the strongest amount of explosives (40kg) it can handle, but can go as far as 90-100 km if packed lighter. A more powerful rocket was launched later that night against Hadera, less than two kilometers from Israel's main power plant. This is M-302, originally a Chinese artillery rocket modified and upgraded by Syria sold to Iran and smuggled to Gaza. It weighs 600kg with a war head of up to 175 though unguided and inaccurate it can reach up to 200km.

Israel estimates that around 400 of these missiles existed in the Gaza arsenal, split between Hamas and the Islamic Jihad before the night's barrage: a dozen were fired over the course of Tuesday evening and Wednesday morning, most of them either intercepted by the Iron Dome or left to hit open spaces. It is clear that without Iran's funding and supplies, the Islamist organization does not have a sufficient number in its cache to fire these treasures at an indiscriminate rate. With its limited supply, neither Hamas nor other militants will part quickly with these missiles. It is using these weapons as sparingly as possible.

The situation in Israel today - kidnappings, murders, and rockets rampant -is reminiscent of both October 2000, the critical moments before the second intifada, and November 2012, when Tel Aviv residents peeked out from their bubble for the first time since the intifada and realized that enemy missiles could reach their neighborhoods and force them to rethink just how relaxed to be in the midst of war on the southern front. For Tel Aviv and Haifa residents, scurrying from such far-range explosives-loaded missiles is a far-gone memory, last seen in 1991 during the Gulf War.

Hamas and its militant compatriots – jihadists which negate its rule - in the Gaza Strip know that 32 percent of the population in Jerusalem, mostly in its east and north, are Muslim. It has and will continue to aim its weapons away from this divisive community, focusing the large rockets on the Judean hills where the main Israel Defense Forces base in the region is located. Its attacks on Tel Aviv are far more indiscriminate: the residential center of this main city is as fair a target as a school in its north or a club in its south.

Israelis will continue to balk at the sound of the sirens and return to agenda immediately, as the south takes the real hits. Tel Aviv is not Sderot. Hamas and the Islamic Jihad have a limited arsenal they are unlikely to waste in a single night, and a truce between the sides is likely to be achieved before any real damage on the Israeli center can be achieved.

Israelis should be alert now, but not alarmed. They know now where to run in case of missiles – their municipalities have been told to prepare – and they know to heed the advice of local experts. They also know that just as Israel wants to avoid escalation, so does Hamas does not want an escalation – it has more to lose than Israel.

The recent days' attacks are a threat in response to threat, a mutual trade between Gaza and Israel. The Palestinian unity pact is on fragile hold and thus Hamas' security and support is waning. Both Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas recognize the hubris in this latest round of war games, and Hamas on its end is well aware too.

The Gaza front opened as Israel and the Palestinian Authority were engaged in solving the crisis of the four kidnapped teens'; From the start, Netanyahu's aim was to prove to Abbas that Hamas is indeed a terrorist group unworthy of a unity pact. In this sense, he has won – Abbas cannot sanctify his unity with Hamas as long as the rockets continue. And the Israeli public will continue to refuse its ever possibility – and thus a chance of an inclusive peace agreement with the two Palestinian territories - as long as the attacks continue on both fronts.

The cycle of violence and revenge continue.

Monday, July 7, 2014

Israel's fear of abandoning Jewish morality will backfire

Four days after a Palestinian teenager was kidnapped outside of an East Jerusalem mosque and burned alive in a forest nearby, the Shin Bet revealed partial details of its investigation: Six Israeli Jews believed to belong to an ad-hoc extremist group have been arrested.

A cloud of secrecy has hovered over the police investigation, but suspicions that Jewish rightists were behind the murder was clear from the start, in both the Israeli and Palestinian public. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu himself condemned the murder immediately after on the basis of it having been the act of Jewish extremists, even as a strict gag order kept the details of the probe undercover.

Rumors began flying as the police kept mum that 16-year-old Mohammed Abu-Khdeir was killed by members of his own family over unsubstantiated claims that he was a homosexual, or by a rival clan for some yet-to-be-determined settling of debts. The teenager's family insisted that this was not an honor killing and that their son was a good student with no enemies. The false claims continued to circulate, with the Israeli right-wing eager to prove to themselves and to others that Jews could not be behind such a heinous crime.

There was little doubt that this was the work of Jewish terrorists. The abduction was carried out less than 12 hours after the three Israeli teenagers abducted and murdered three weeks before were laid to rest and amidst rampant demonstrations of Israeli Jews in Jerusalem calling for blood and death to the Arabs.

The gag order was sealed again Sunday just hours after the initial details of the investigation were revealed, at the behest of the Shin Bet, which is holding the Jewish suspects in custody. One small piece of information managed to filter through before the file was removed from public information, however: that the same six suspects were linked to the abduction attempt of a 9-year-old boy in the same East Jerusalem neighborhood of Shoafat just a day before Abu Kheidar's kidnap and grisly murder.

Netanyahu again condemned the murder, in his first press conference in more than two years. "Israel does not differentiate between terror," Netanyahu said, vowing to crack down on Jewish extremists with the same vigorousness Israel uses against Palestinians. "As I condemn the calls of death to Arabs, I condemn calls of death to Jews." In the same breath, he followed by declaring that what differentiates Israel from its neighbors is that the latter welcomes murderers and terrorists and names streets and squares after them.

Netanyahu's weakened condemnation, to play into the Israeli sentiment that Jews could not be responsible for such an act, were followed by a harsher and more surprising remark by his right-wing Economy Minister, Naftali Bennett, who proposed subjecting Jewish terrorists to the same legal retributions accorded to Palestinians convicted of security offenses.

The prime minister's quick clarification of Jews' moral superiority will do little to douse the flames engulfing Israel, nor will the gag order reinstated on the investigation, leaving open conspiracy theories and unsettled suspicions.



Arab rioters have taken to the streets of Israel, from Wadi Ara to the highways leading to wealthy suburbs in both north and south, hurling firebombs and stones, and lighting tires aflame. Israel's highways are beginning to look like the West Bank or East Jerusalem. The riots subsided briefly on Sunday morning and resumed at full force on Sunday evening, following news of the arrest. Police were forced to shut down major thoroughfares over the course of the demonstration, as the rioters targeted cars entering the Jewish neighborhoods. Nearly 200 demonstrators were arrested in a single day of clashes.

Jewish claims to moral superiority must not be taken at face value. Extremists are capable of and have carried out far more extensive massacres over the course of Israel's recent history. Baruch Goldstein's murder of 29 Palestinians in Hebron is the most well-known of these attacks, but many other examples exist: the Bat Ayin underground's plan to wipe out a Palestinian girls' school, deserted soldier Eden Natan-Zada's murder of four innocent Arab passengers on a bus in Shfaram, contractor Asher Weisgan's targeted shootout of four of his Palestinian workers, the arson of a home in Sinjil which trapped and killed an entire Palestinian family.

The Israeli Arab demonstrations and concurrent clashes with police have drawn the war between Jews and Arab across the Green Line, into the affluent suburbs of secular Israel. Their riots were preceded by a venomous popular campaign among right-wing Israelis – not even those considered extreme - calling for bloody revenge over the murder of the three Israeli teens. What will stop these Jewish revenge-seekers from countering their Arab counterparts in Israel in a bloody face-off?

Those who are capable of burning a teenager alive are capable of taking up arms against their enemy masses in the Israeli Arab sector. The Israeli government, however, is not capable of issuing a firm declaration without forgiving society for its Jewish morality in comparison with its neighbors and the "lone" extremists responsible for these attacks.

Unless Netanyahu acts on his pledge of cracking down on the right-wing violence, his claims of Jewish superiority will backfire and leave Israel not only in further isolation but in a bloody sectarian war.

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Israel should take West Bank kidnapping as chance for peace, not war

Police evacuating Arabs from riots in Jerusalem / Olivier Fittousi, Haaretz

Soon after the three kidnapped teens were laid to rest side-by-side in an emotional funeral attended by tens of thousands of mourners, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's security cabinet of senior ministers convened for the second time in 24 hours to determine its response to the attack and to the barrage of rockets that have been lobbied at southern Israel in the weeks that followed.

Just a few kilometers away, in the center of Jerusalem, dozens of right-wing Israelis gathered not for a vigil, but to cast their anger and frustration on any Palestinian they could find. They rampaged through the streets shouting racist slogans, hurling rocks and firing pepper spray, demanding "revenge" and death to the Arabs.

Five Palestinians were wounded and some 50 rioters were detained. The mob on Tuesday night carried the spirit of their comrades who chose a similar course of action the evening before, when it emerged that security forces has found the boys' bodies, 19 days after they were whisked away from a hitchhiking stand in the West Bank.

Before the meeting, Netanyahu and his defense minister, Moshe Ya'alon, lay out to the public the three tasks facing Israel's defense establishment: first, to find the abductors and all accomplices; second to destroy Hamas' infrastructure and membership in the West Bank; and third, "to expand the operation as far as required" to wipe out the military capabilities of the ruling Islamist organization in the Gaza Strip.

"We will not rest and we will not relax until we have reached every last one of them. It doesn't matter where they try to hide. We will reach them all," Netanyahu said.

Despite Netanyahu's harsh words, the cabinet is torn on how to respond, particularly on whether to turn its energies also on Gaza rather than just focusing its search on Hamas in the West Bank. The majority in cabinet fears that a violent circle will result in an all-out war, which both sides are eager to avoid.

Israel has struck Gaza targets by the dozens in the last few weeks, in response to the near hundred rockets fired at Israel, with the goal of reaching Hamas' operational ranks in the coastal territory.

Hamas is used to these reprisals, however, and most of its senior commanders have already taken refuge underground. The only exposed targets at this point are the low-level militants doing the footwork in Gaza and the weapons warehouses they man.

Ya'alon, for his part, while showing caution on the military front, is keeping up his image as a shoot-from-the-hip right-wing politician, proposing that a new settlement be created in response to the kidnapping in memory of the three teens. His suggestion is no less provocative than the activities of the vigilante rightists roaming the streets of Jerusalem seeking revenge with their eyes closed.

In the West Bank, the Palestinian Authority is considering its next move just as carefully. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas held out an olive branch in vulnerable hands three weeks ago when he told a forum of Arab foreign ministers, in their native language at a summit in Jeddah, that he condemned the kidnapping and resolved to find the perpetrators.

Abbas plans to approach the international community in a plea to halt Israeli military moves, fearing the domino effect it will create: a popular uprising, a third intifada, and a renewal of unrest in the West Bank that hasn't been felt in nearly a decade.

Hundreds of homes have been overturned and nearly 500 Palestinians have been arrested since Israel embarked on its operation to find the boys and their kidnappers. Palestinians will not tolerate the overnight raids and incursions much longer; the majority, unaffiliated with Hamas, wants to live in a state of stability, to escape the sense of occupation, without fear for family, property and peace of mind.

The defense establishment must focus on pinpointing the terrorists and their accomplices, but need not turn the West Bank upside down in its search – and most certainly should not open a wide-scale operation in the Gaza Strip. Such a move will only escalate enmity on both the Israeli and Palestinian sides.

More air strikes on Gaza will be met with multiple rocket barrages on the south; extensive raids in the West Bank will find its match with a populist response from angry young Palestinians; that uprising will spur further violence from the right-wing Israeli extremists. And so forth and so forth. There will be no end to the cycle.

The deadline for renewing peace talks expired in late April, but such dates are flexible; Israel and the Palestinians have been going at this process for 21 years. Israel should take the opportunity to see Abbas and his Palestinian Authority as a partner for peace, and together form a true partnership to wipe out the extremism within both Israel and the West Bank.

Israel is intent on destroying Abbas' unity agreement with Hamas. Attacking the West Bank and the Gaza Strip will only strengthen their fraternity. Israel now has the chance to fortify a bond with Abbas that will ensure security on both sides of the Jordan River, for the Israelis and the Palestinians on each side. Abbas has shown he is ready. Netanyahu must do the same.

Monday, June 30, 2014

With bodies of kidnapped teens found, Israel is now waging war against Hamas

It was clear to the Shin Bet from the very beginning of its search for the three abducted teenagers and their kidnappers in the West Bank that there was little chance of finding the boys alive.

The investigation began seven hours after the boys were kidnapped, due to the failure of the police to operate accordingly, to respond to one of the boys' desperate plea for help or to track the call in the hours that followed.

The Shin Bet relied on two means of intelligence and two spheres of search over the last 19 days: They employed human intelligence (Shin Bet case officers, sources in the field, using agents and collaborators, and forensic evidence) and signet (wiretapping and analysis of data). Based on the lack of forensics aside from the burnt car abandoned by the kidnappers, and to the fact that there were no claims of responsibility from any individual or organization, the Shin Bet did not have even the slightest evidence to assess that the three were still alive.

Based on that assessment, the Shin Bet opened two spheres of search: one to locate the kidnappers and the other to locate the teens – or their bodies.

Security forces raided Hebron, near the site of the kidnapping and the believed home base of the kidnappers. The Shin Bet had listed Marwan Kwasame and Amar Abu Aysha as prime suspects within three days of the kidnapping, after learning that the two Hamas militants had disappeared just hours before the incident. Both have a history of militancy in the Hebron area, and both have been arrested in Israel in the past.

The Israeli forces turned homes upside down by the dozen, arrested hundreds of Hamas operatives and suspects, and searched in the river valleys and farms surrounding the area for some evidence of eithers' whereabouts.

The Shin Bet managed to narrow down the huge swath of land near Hebron to the exact spot where they found the boys' bodies at about 6 P.M. on Monday evening, but they still have not managed to track down the kidnappers. The manhunt is still underway, and the Shin Bet is certain it will manage to locate them. It believes that the kidnappers have not managed to escape the West Bank or even find refuge in the northern part of the territory, and estimates that they are still hiding in the Hebron area.

Two main questions, aside from the kidnappers' location, remain. The first is whether the kidnappers intended all along to abduct and kill, or whether they panicked in their attempt to bargain their hostages for a prisoner release and shot their victims in the head after one of the boys made a desperate call to the police hotline and whispered, "They kidnapped me."

As neither Kwasame nor Abu Aysha hold particularly high ranks in the Hamas, the second question is whether they carried out the kidnapping on their own accord, believing it to be their obligations as members of the Islamist organization, or if they were ordered to do so from the higher ranks.

The riddle can only be solved once the kidnappers have been found and the other Hamas operatives detained in the last week and a half of raids have been interrogated. The search for the kidnappers will continue and so will the overnight raids in Hebron.


Infographic created by Haaretz

Meanwhile, a fierce second front has erupted on the Gaza border. Some 70 rockets have been fired at the Gaza border communities since Operation Brother's Keeper began, the most severe of which struck a factory in the southern city of Sderot and ignited a massive fire.

The rocket attacks have been carried out mostly by splinter militant groups like an offshoot of the Palestinian Resistance Committees, and not by Hamas, exploiting Israel's second volatile front as its security and intelligence forces are focused on the West Bank.

Regardless of who is launching the rockets, Israel holds Hamas responsible for every attack, whether launched by those loyal to the ruling movement or rebel factions who refuse its authority.

The Israel Defense Forces has responded with harsh strikes on the coastal territory, killing more than half a dozen militants on their way to carry out a rocket attack. As the situation around the Gaza Strip continues, the IDF is intensifying its operation, with a focus on targeted assassinations in addition to pinpointed hits on the lower-level militants firing the rockets.

Israel's security cabinet convened late Monday after the bodies were found to determine further course of action, a meeting that was followed immediately by a new round of air strikes on Gaza. Former deputy minister of strategic affairs, Tzachi Hanegbi, has said it is not clear how many of Hamas' leaders will remain alive following the IDF strikes.

The trained eyes of Israel's defense establishment are on alert to threats from both the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, and to the developments in its neighbors to the north, Iraq and Syria. After a near two-year period of calm, escalation has resumed. Israel has made it clear that it will not tolerate any attacks on its territory or its citizens, and will use its mighty hand to stop them.

Israel's political goal, from the beginning of the operation, was to convince Mahmoud Abbas to annul the Palestinian Authority's partnership with its former rival Hamas. With the recent barrage of rockets from Gaza, Israel is using the opportunity to take the matter into its own hand and strike Hamas in its heartland. The Palestinian factions acting on their own and firing rockets will only encourage a harsher Israeli response.

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Hezbollah, Al-Qaida or lone wolf? Brussels shooting bears marks of Islamist world war's new face


When a professional gunman, wearing a baseball cap and carrying a simple sports bag, walked into the Brussels Jewish Museum last Saturday and opened fire on four innocent victims, killing three and leaving the fourth with critical brain injuries, the media in both Israel and Belgium were quick to posit that this was the work of a well-oiled Islamist machine targeting members of the Israeli intelligence community.

The fact that Emanuel and Mira Riva, who were killed in the shootout, were both employees of Israeli government factions under the auspices of the Prime Minister's Office, led to early and uncorroborated assumptions that the two – or at least the wife - were Mossad operatives and deliberate targets of the shooter, tied to either Hezbollah or Al-Qaida.

While the calculated manner of the shooting, as well as the choice of a Jewish institution, indeed point to the hand of a trained Islamist terrorist, it is highly doubtful that the Rivas were specifically targeted as representatives of the Israeli intelligence community.

It is true that Hezbollah has long targeted Israeli and Jewish targets the world over, a threat it intensified in the wake of its senior commander Imad Mughniyeh's assassination in 2009, with a particular focus on Israelis part and parcel to the office of those perpetuators – the Mossad, or better known in covert Israeli speak, the Prime Minister's Office.

But it is also true that neither of the Rivas was a Mossad operative: both were accountants, he a former employee of the Nativ immigration agency that aided Russian Jewish emigres, and she a clerk. Neither were prime targets for the organization, as an Israeli officer would have been.

While the possibility remains that the attack was orchestrated by affiliates of Hezbollah or Al-Qaida, there is little to indicate that it was ordered by the higher ranks of either.

The evidence collected so far, including the lack of organizational support at the scene of the crime and the failure to pinpoint a network of other suspects, indicate that the shooting was carried out by either a local cell of the Islamic Jihad or by a lone gunman.

The Brussels shooter was a professional; that is a fact that cannot be disputed. With little forensic evidence to narrow down the identity of the gunman, investigators are relying on security footage from the museum, which captured him walking calmly into the tourist attraction, pulling out an AK-47 Kalashnikov rifle, shooting at his targets, and in just as measured a walk with which he entered, leaving the premises after completing the deed. He even remembered to zip his bag. Despite earlier reports, the gunman was alone at the scene of the shooting, and no getaway car awaited him, nor is there evidence that he received on-spot logistical support.

A viable suspect has been arrested, a 29-year-old Frenchmen of Algerian descent, named Mehdi Nemmouche. He was caught by authorities at a bus station in Marseille, en route from Amsterdam with a stop in Brussels. In his bag, which French police say was searched as part of a routine drug inspection, was an AK-47 Kalshnikov rifle, a revolver and ammunition, a GoPro camera said to be worn by the Brussels shooter and the baseball cap and clothing seen in CCTV on the body of the gunman during the attack.

A French police source called Nemmouche, who is still in custody and maintained the right to silence in the first 24 hours of his arrest, "an expert gunman and a crap fugitive." Shortly after Nemmouche's arrest, authorities released a video in which a voice, apparently belonging to the Frenchman, describes the shooting as an "attack against the Jews."

Nemmouche was not stopped by chance. He was already circulating in the French database as a national who had traveled to Syria to train and fight with jihadis there. His inspiration for Islamist warfare was apparently gleaned during his near year-long stay in a French prison, where he was incarcerated for robbing a convenience store.

The Brussels shooting bears remarkable similarities to the attack in Toulouse in 2012, when gunman Mohamed Mera, affiliated with Jihad but acting alone, shot and killed four people outside a Jewish school.

Like Mera, the Brussels gunman wore a personal miniature camera on his chest. And like Mera, his was clearly the work of an Islamist targeting Jews, though not specifically Israelis, and not necessarily ordered by the higher ranks of a global Jihad movement.

Just hours after the attack in Brussels, two Jewish men were assaulted leaving a synagogue in Paris and left in serious condition, harping back to the grotesque murder of Ilan Halimi, a 23-year-old French Jew tortured, burned and dismembered by a "lone" group in 2007.

If the Brussels attack was indeed carried out without instruction by the greatest terrorist groups of our time, the act of a "lone" wolf must not be dismissed as less threatening than if it were. The other two anti-Jewish attacks this week - both at the Kansas Jewish center and in Paris – were also carried out by "lone wolves".

A world war is on the rise, by an army of rogue soldiers whose motives are the same but do not answer to a specific commander. Thousands of Westerners have joined this war, both within the ranks of the jihadi groups in the Middle East and on their own accord in Europe and the United States.

Nowhere is safe, not on the green lawns of Kansas, nor on the cobblestone streets of Brussels, and certainly not in the war-torn cities of Syria. These lone wolves are not alone.

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

From Beirut to Jerusalem, a run for Mideast peace


Ultramarathon runner Pat Farmer has already clocked nearly 1,000 kilometers in less than two weeks, but his mission is not yet complete: The former Australian politician still has more than 400 to go before completing his goal of crossing the Middle East, at 80 kilometers a day, in the name of peace, and more importantly, unity.

The Middle East Peace Run isn’t the 52-year-old runner’s first ultramarathon, nor is it his most physically ambitious. He finished a 20,000-kilometer run from the North to South Poles, through 14 countries, in 2011. When the founder of Budo for Peace, an Israeli nonprofit run by fellow Australian Danny Hakim, approached him last year with the idea of a peace run, Farmer was already mentally prepared for the challenge. He had felt compelled to come to the region, he said, but wanted to do more than just compete in a race.

There is no doubt in Farmer’s mind that he can finish the 1,400-kilometer mission – quitting is not an option. It’s that mindset, he believes, that can help bring about change.

Farmer’s goal is to “inspire the people on the ground” to have hope in the prospect of peace, and to encourage them to dedicate their own running, whether with him or on their own, to the cause. “I am hoping that when we finish we have hundreds of thousands of people dedicating their run to this cause,” regardless of the distances they cover. “That’s a substantial message to bring to the leaders,” he added, to show the government that its constituents “want peace.”

“You can’t get anything more concrete than that,” Farmer told me in telephone interview after crossing the border Saturday from Aqaba, Jordan, to Eilat, a southern Israeli resort. When men come together for peace, there is hope in the world, and without hope there is nothing, he added, paraphrasing an old adage. “Let’s take this message to the leaders.”

Budo for Peace founder Hakim, who moved to Israel in 2000, has dedicated his life here to bridging gaps through sport, mostly martial arts, a discipline he describes not as a mode of self-defense, but rather a meditation in patience and tolerance.

Hakim met Farmer in Sydney, at a Friday night dinner hosted by the former’s sister and brother-in-law, old friends of Farmer’s. The idea for a Middle East unity run had been brewing in Hakim’s mind already, and he popped the question to Farmer. “To go from the North to South Pole, that’s meshuga [crazy], but to from Beirut to Jerusalem, that’s impossible,” Hakim told Farmer. When the seasoned ultramarathoner asked why, Hakim replied: “Let’s go for a run together and I’ll explain.”

Breaking down barriers


The run is being called a bid to promote peace, but Hakim says that misses the point of the endeavor. “Some people think it’s political, what we’re doing,” Hakim said. “But the message is very simple. [Farmer] wants to show the world that [this region] is not what you see on television.”

This is the first time in modern history that a run of this kind has been organized, and it’s not just the political barriers, but rather the media's image of the region, the enmity between Arab and Jewish neighbors and the bird’s-eye-view of people living across the ocean, that Hakim, Farmer and the crew of supporters and film people with him want to help break down. “It’s the extremists – what I call the bullies – that you see on TV,” said Hakim.


In Israel, people of all political and religious backgrounds – whether secular or ultra-Orthodox, rightists and leftists, or fans of the rival Maccabi and Hapoel sports teams – are planning to join Farmer for segments of the run. Anyone can join, be it for 2 kilometers, a 20-kilometer challenge, or the full 80 kilometers of the day. Enthusiasts in Lebanon, including well-known singer Daniella Rahme, in Jordan and in Farmer's brief tour of Israel so far, have done so already.

Since crossing into Israel, Farmer and his team have been joined by a number of runners, including a 16-year-old who jogged 30 kilometers with Farmer, and said that while he wants to join a Israel Defense Forces combat unit to protect his country, “if there is peace, I don’t have to go to the army.”

The cost of running for two weeks and covering 1,400 kilometers has totalled $300,000, half of which Farmer managed to raise for himself, in good part from Lebanese businessmen, who Hakim said were interested in showing that they are pro-peace and pro-Israel.

The response in the cities and towns in Arab countries and here, which he's passed through since beginning his journey on May 1 – in Lebanon, then across Jordan and into Israel – has been “brilliant,” Farmer said. In addition to running with anyone who wants to join, he has organized a number of events at schools across Israel, to allow him a chance to talk to and engage the younger generation. Kids from the rocket-battered southern Israeli town of Sderot, Hakim noted, were, for example, extremely excited about taking part. “You only see them running into shelters [on TV],” he said.

The idea of trying to spread a political message may be a deterrent to some, Hakim admitted. “People want to meet someone who [struggles] to overcome challenges,” he said. “I’m sure if we didn’t call it Middle East and we didn’t call it peace, we’d get thousands more runners.”

Tourism Ministry balks

Hakim managed to secure financial assistance and logistical support for the endeavor from Israel’s Foreign Ministry and the municipality of Jerusalem, where the run will conclude with a celebratory ceremony on May 19. The municipalities of Tel Aviv, Haifa and Eilat also threw in their support, as have private organizations including Magen David Adom emergency services and the Saucony athletics company. Farmer and his crew will be staying at hotels that are part of the Dan chain throughout Israel. The governments of Lebanon and Jordan and the Palestinian Authority also provided logistical and security support, after being lobbied by Farmer.

A few weeks before Farmer's visit, Budo for Peace approached the Israeli Tourism Ministry and requested tangible support in the form of two vans and two guides, or, alternatively, funding, but it was turned down. Ministerial officials later invited Farmer to meet Minister Uzi Landau, who they said was planning to provide certificates to the runner and his crew at the closing ceremony in Jerusalem. The ministry also offered to provide funding for hosting foreign journalists who are covering the run, and to help in the project's public relations campaign abroad, said Tourism Ministry spokeswoman Anat Shihor Aronson.

Hakim and the staff at Budo for Peace called this an empty gesture, however, and said they preferred that the ministry withdraw its belated agreement to cooperate and not attend the Jerusalem event, after denying logistical and other support for the run. In the end, Landau will not attend and the ministry is taking no part in the project.

“For us to get no sponsorship and support – I didn’t want that to happen,” said Hakim. Nor did Farmer, he added. “I don’t want the Tourism Ministry to have a bad name … They do a good job… [but] I didn’t want them to get credit they don’t deserve.”

“It could be the budget, it could be political,” said Hakim, trying to explain the ministry's lack of support. “I really get a feeling that politicians are worried that it’s a left-wing thing, or that peace – you talk about peace, you think you’re a loser. People like to back winners, [but when it comes to] anything to do with peace, you’re a loser, not a winner, and that’s the feeling I got from some members of parliament, or some departments. Pat is about humanity, it’s about what we have in common. The most important thing we [and the Arab countries] have in common is that we have a terrible image. And he can change that.”

“I see this as a fantastic PR opportunity for Israel and they don’t see it,” said Hakim, of the Tourism Ministry. The Dan chain saw it as a boon for tourism, he added, but the ministry didn’t. “Those who saw the opportunity jumped at it.”

The decision to turn down Hakim’s initial request for financial assistance was a purely professional consideration, the Tourism Ministry said in response to the my request for clarification.

“The Tourism Ministry receives many requests for support of events, and they are considered in a logical manner, in accordance with the type of support requested and to what extent the event will encourage tourism [in Israel],” spokeswoman Shihor-Aronson explained. The organizers requested production assistance, the ministry said, a type of support that is “not in line with the ministry’s policy, which is to enable significant world exposure of the event.”

Forging ties

Farmer, a former Australian MP, forged connections with a number of Middle Eastern ambassadors before embarking on his journey, including Israel’s envoy in Canberra. He hopes to meet with government officials while here to pass on his message, and to help further the already close ties between the two countries.

His initial dream of being able to run directly from Beirut to Jerusalem was thwarted by the absence of any border crossing between the two countries, and Egypt was discarded from the itinerary due to the instability there and the arrest in Cairo in December of an Australian journalist.

After running through Lebanon, from the Cedars through Tripoli and Beirut, Farmer flew to Jordan, as there was no other safe option for border crossing. He ran south from Amman to the port of Aqaba, where he crossed into Eilat and began his journey northward again, in Israel. He has a stop planned in Jaffa on Wednesday, for a ceremony at the Peres Center for Peace, after which he will continue on toward the Arab town of Jisr al-Zarqa, north to Haifa, east to Nazareth and south to Afula, from where he will cross into the Palestinian Authority to the West Bank cities of Nablus, Ramallah and Bethlehem, then on to Jerusalem, where he will complete the run.

Farmer runs 80 kilometers in about eight hours every day. He trained by doing 20-40 kilometers a day in anticipation of this particular run, and has more than 30 years of "ultra-running" experiences under his belt. In this region of the world, Farmer has faced mountainous areas and hot deserts that could put any hardened runner out, and has pushed through the bruises, the aches and even vomiting on the side of the road to achieve his goal. “You have to accept pain,” he said. “Nothing worthwhile is ever easy.”

“To be honest, I have no ultimate respect for myself and my own body,” Farmer told me. “I think the cause that I am running for goes beyond my own personal well-being. That’s why I am pushing on the big kilometers,” he said, instead of taking it easy by doing 5 kilometers per day during a months-long run. “I want people to know that I am prepared to hurt,” he added.

What keeps him going, even during the toughest moments? “The cause,” Farmer said. “I want people to know… Please keep forging ahead, please don’t give up …. You don’t lose until you quit.”

Originally published in Haaretz